Showing posts with label Love The Quick Kick. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Love The Quick Kick. Show all posts

Sunday, January 11, 2009

NFL Playoffs: Deus ex McNabb ...



Please don't see that as a mistake. Sometimes errors reveal the larger truths.

Someone at TSN.ca was subtly commenting on the fear of a nine-win team representing the NFC in the Super Bowl. It even appeared almost 20 hours before the No. 1 seed in the NFC, the New York Giants, folded against the Philadephia Eagles in the early game today, which Football Outsiders correctly predicted.

It is not a bad thing if teams that didn't reach double digits in victories during the regular season reach the Super Bowl. Mediocrity is rewarded every day in our society, so why people would not tolerate that in pro football is beyond comprehension. I know, you're looking for escapism, not reality thrown back in your face like a bad punt into the wind in Buffalo.

No doubt a lot of media chatter about the Giants will dwell on Eli Manning's mental toughness as reflected by his team's inability to finish drives. The inference left unsaid it that it's proof of some huge character flaw. It was actually a matter of simple mechanics. Some passers can handle Giants Stadium's notorious January winds. It was obvious that Manning could not from the first series of the game, when Elisha had Steve Smith open deep and the ball was blown off-course and fell incomplete.

On the next Giants possession, Manning tried a play-action pass to the same side of the field, the right sideline. The ball sailed out of the receiver's reach and Philly's Asante Samuel returned the gift interception to New York's two-yard line, setting up the first touchdown. Talk about foreshadowing.

The Giants, as you remember, won the Super Bowl last season by winning games in Tampa Bay, Dallas, Green Bay (it was cold, but not windy) and Arizona, when Manning could throw effectively without worrying about the wind. Manning is now 0-2 at home in the playoffs. The Giants haven't scored a touchdown in either game. Sometimes, it is that simple, although hey, there's a huge media maw to feed where pro athletes are either heroes or choking freaking dogs.

It is quite possible that Fox's Troy Aikman might have mentioned that 2005 shutout loss, but the mute button was on most of the afternoon as a prevent defence against Joe Buck. Of course, in broadcaster cliche-speak, that was a different Eli Manning, since he was only in his second season in '05. He might be more mature and more savvy, but no amount of age and wisdom is going to make up for what kind of ball he throws.

Anyway, laying objectivity aside, seeing the Eagles advance at the Giants' expense was sweet. Drew Magary at Deadspin beat everyone to this last week, but Eagles defensive co-ordinator Jim Johnson is a football geek's favourite football lifer. His unit has been the best one on the field in both of Philly's playoff wins.

Johnson is 67 years old, which means he will never get a chance at running his own team. He's not even the best known Jim Johnson in pro football. The Eagles' identity has always been quarterback Donovan McNabb, even though they've always been a balanced team.

A NFL owner would rather have someone who projects renewal and youthful enthusiasm.One of his former assistants, John Harbaugh, has Baltimore in the AFC title game; another, the Minnesota Vikings defensive coordinator Leslie Frazier, is a candidate to run his own team. The Giants' defensive boss, Steve Spagnuolo, is also in the running for one of several vacancies, so in other words, the coordinators from the teams the Eagles eliminated are in line to move up the football food chain.

There's the vicarious joy for Jim Johnson, plus the Giants embody loathsomeness. No one wants New York teams to win too often. The topper today was a boneheaded challenge in the fourth quarter by their crabass coach, Tom Coughlin, after Derrick Ward, was obviously short on a third-down running play. Coughlin actually made a bigger blunder earlier, by forcing the Giants to go into the wind in the first quarter.

It was milquetoast. It was fourth-and-inches and the Giants, down by nine points, only had two precious timeouts remaining. Risking a timeout for the sake of two feet in field position was pound-foolish. A team which led the league in rushing ought to be able to get two feet. Naturally, after the refs' spot was upheld, Manning got stuffed on a quarterback sneak. It was brilliant.

Anyway, not to overdo do the here's-what-happened-in-sports-and-here's-what-I-think, but here's a couple other random thoughts.

Crime, punishment and Joe Buck: The Fox play-by-play man made a smug reference to Plaxico Burress "took himself out" of the picture, referring to how the Giants suspended him after his handgun charge. Pro Football Talk noted that in the second game today, San Diego's Vincent Jackson, who had a drunk-driving charge, scored the first touchdown of the game. The second TD of the game was scored by Santonio Holmes, who was charged with marijuana possession earlier this year. Neither player was benched by his team after being arrested.

Point being: The moral high ground is nice in the NFL. Winning is nicer. Don't count on hearing that from Joe Buck.

Best beauty use of the quick kick: It was mentioned a couple weeks ago that the quick kick, where the quarterback punts from a standard scrimmage formation, is a great underused gambit.

Early on in the San Diego-Pittsburgh game, the Steelers had fourth-and-8 on the 34-yard line. A 51-yard field-goal try was out, since no one has ever made a kick that long at Heinz Field, known to have the worst playing surface in the NFL. The Steelers lined up like they were going for it, but QB Ben Roethlisberger, backpedalled a few steps, took the snap and left-footed a punt that rolled dead at the nine-yard line, pinning San Diego. Pittsburgh forced a punt, and Holmes returned it 68 yards for a touchdown. That might not have happened if the Chargers had started with better field position.

Hidebound coaching, Fisher is King: There is a debate at Pro-football-reference over Tennessee Titans coach Jeff Fisher opting for a tying field goal on a fourth-and-inches situation with 4:00 left Saturday. It is always schadenfreulicious when a team has the safe call backfire, as it did when the Baltimore Ravens moved downfield for the winning points, eliminating Tennessee.

That doesn't mean it was the wrong call. Coaches play for the tie or for overtime all the time. No one remembers the times it worked and Tennessee's defence had played well enough to give Fisher confidence that his team would get a meaningful chance to score again.

Oz right now: One subplot of the NFC title game between the Eagles (9-6-1) and Arizona Cardinals (9-7) is that it means a former Australian Rules Football player will play in the Super Bowl. How can you not be excited for the Aussies, choosing with punter to root for, Philly's Sav Rocca or 'Zona's Ben Graham?

He does do that: Pacifist Viking had an odd observation about Joe Buck: "Before a game on FOX, watch the intro with Joe Buck and Troy Aikman. While Aikman talks, Buck watches Aikman, but every few seconds he turns to look at the camera with an ultra-serious expression, as if he's checking to make sure we're paying attention. It is a very unnatural, robotic movement -- he seems compelled to artificially turn his head toward the camera every few seconds."

Fun factoid: The NFC championship game will be the 114th meeting between the Cardinals and Eagles. The all-time series is tied at 54-54-5.

Sunday, December 28, 2008

Stratagems: Not punting the football

Someone else is using math to ruin sports.

Gregg Easterbrook at ESPN.com has often Don't Punt proselytizers who have produced analyses saying that punting the ball away on fourth down is a poor percentage play. The pointyheads have evidently got to a high school coach in Little Rock, Arkansas, named Kevin Kelley. His team, the Pulaski Bruins, won the state championship without punting all season.

The numbers say that Kelley is right to go for it on every fourth down and, according to the Rivals High article, go for an onside kick on about 75% of the team's kickoffs.
If Pulaski converts on fourth down, it creates a momentum change similar to a turnover. Other high school coaches have told Kelley they would rather see his team punt.

The Bruins even avoid punting when the defense has stopped them inside their own 10-yard line.

"You can just tell people are in the stands thinking, 'You're an idiot,' " Kelley said.

... If Pulaski has a fourth-and-8 at its own 5-yard line, Kelley said his explosive offense likely will convert a first down at least 50 percent of the time. If it fails to convert, statistical data from the college level shows that an opponent acquiring the ball inside the 10-yard line scores a touchdown 90 percent of the time. If Pulaski punts away (i.e., a 40-yard punt with a 10-yard return) the other team will start with the ball on the 38-yard line and score a touchdown 77 percent of the time. The difference is only 13 percent.
Anyone who has covered high school football, speaking from experience, has probably wondered why the stronger teams don't call for onside kicks at least half the time, aside from situations where the outcome is not in doubt. The up men on the return team often have little experience handling the ball. The sight of the ball coming toward them when it's not expected can cause a young athlete to panic.

In a general sense, these are fun ideas to play around with on a Sunday morning before settling in for a NFL Sunday. It comes back to a key principle of being a sports fan that some sports geeks can forget. When a crucial situation comes up, don't think of it in terms of of what a certain coach or team might do, suggest what they should try. You'll live longer.

This is apropos since Denver and San Diego play tonight for the AFC West title – someone has to win it, and laying aside what you might think of Ray Lewis or Bill Belichick, you should be annoyed that an 8-8 team might go into the playoffs ahead of the 10-6 Baltimore Ravens or New England Patriots. In those teams' first meeting this season, as you know, Denver beat San Diego 39-38 after passing up a sure extra point to go for a 2-point conversion in the final minutes.

Right before that play, a newsroom colleague said, "They should go for two." Someone pointed out, "They never do that in the NFL," and he replied, "So what? I want to see them go for two, they should go for two. Don't tell me what you think the coaches will do, tell me what you think they should do." Weak, OK-you-win reply: "Go for two, then."

In that spirit, teams should punt less. Kicking the ball away when the other team knows a punt is coming often does seem like a give-up play. Now there are numbers that confirm as much.

Obviously, field goals are another kind of apple. That involves putting points on the scoreboard. Media types who have roasted the New England Patriots' Bill Belichick and USC's Pete Carroll for ill-fated fourth-down gambles in big games had a point. Going for it on fourth-and-13 in the Super Bowl when your offensive line is being owned will always be dumb.

The quick kick on third down, where the quarterback lines up in the shotgun formation, inches back a few steps and boots the ball away, is also separate.

A fourth-down punt only seems worth it when the punter has a chance to pin a team inside its own 10-yard line. There was a perfect example Saturday of where Don't Punt might have helped a team. The Wisconsin Badgers were down by only four points late in the first half in their Champs Sports Bowl capitulation against Florida State, facing fourth-and-2 on their own 15-yard line. They punted. About 40 seconds later, Florida State scored a touchdown to open a double-digit lead and went on to win 42-13.

It might have ended up that way anyhow (big, slow Big Ten team vs. a big, swift southern team, don't you know). It didn't have to, though.
Keeping the offense on the field on fourth down allows for more creative play-calling. Third-and-long does not have to be a passing down. The Little Rock school can run the ball, throw a screen pass or use any number of formations. Defenses do not know whether to use a nickel or dime defense. And Pulaski's offense has less pressure on third down.
On the previous play, the Badgers faced third-and-6. In their minds, they had one chance to get six yards, not two, so they lined up in a formation that screamed Obvious Passing Situation. Wisconsin is famous for its power running game, but Florida State knew it could sell out for a pass. The Wisconsin receiver caught a short pass and was quickly dropped two yards short of the first down, boom went the punt and soon enough, the rout was on.

It's always enjoyable to think about unorthodox strategies. The Don't Punt strategy seems like a winner. It will not appear in the NFL any time soon, but anything that requires more brainwork for the players and more excitement for fans should be welcome, even the bastards have to resort to introducing empirical evidence.

Related:
Arkansas coach punts traditional game plan (Jeff Merotin, Rivals High; via JonahKeri.com)