Friday, November 21, 2008

CIS Corner: West is good, if not best

Rob Pettapiece's number-crunching should be some grist for the East-West debate that inevitably comes up in OUA men's basketball.

For starters, a certain defending champion (Brock) which is in town this weekend to play Carleton and uOttawa ranks 32nd of 43 teams, despite being 8-0 vs. Canadian competition.

Rob — glory be for having a U of Waterloo man on the blog — has crunched the numbers to come up with the first RPI of the season. The OUA East's top four teams — No. 1 Carleton, No. 8 Ottawa, No. 15 Queen's and No. 16 Toronto — collectively come out ahead of the West's best four.

The Ravens' and Gee-Gees' respective RPIs are commensurate (triple-word score!) with their rankings in the official CIS coaches' poll, which shows the coaches are doing a pretty good job, on balance. Brock, though, snuck in No. 10 — as noted over at cisblog.ca, you cannot not rank the country's lone unbeaten team, so what are you going to do? — 

Again, no one should be married to a stat, but it's the grist for some debate ... Queen's being No. 15 despite a sub-.500 record should buoy hopes that coach Rob Smart is on the right track by playing a tough early-season schedule by lining up his young Golden Gaels team vs. McGill, Toronto, Waterloo and Western.
  1. Carleton (9-1) .610
  2. UBC (10-1) .604
  3. Windsor (7-2) .604
  4. UVic (8-3) .583
  5. StFX (9-2) .576
  6. Concordia (5-1) .565
  7. McGill (10-3) .564
  8. Ottawa (10-2) .547
  9. Calgary (10-1) .545
  10. Dalhousie (9-3) .543
  11. Cape Breton (6-2) .538
  12. Western (5-5) .536
  13. Simon Fraser (5-3) .532
  14. Trinity Western (4-4) .532
  15. Queen's (4-7) .528
  16. Toronto (6-5) .525
  17. Laval (2-6) .523
  18. Saskatchewan (4-6) .515
  19. McMaster (4-4) .504
  20. Waterloo (8-3) .502
  21. Laurier (5-6) .500
  22. UQAM (3-6) .500
  23. Lakehead (1-7) .498
  24. Alberta (3-6) .486
  25. Lethbridge (4-10) .482
  26. Ryerson (4-6) .480
  27. Guelph (5-3) .480
  28. UPEI (3-6) .475
  29. Bishop's (3-7) .472
  30. Regina (3-4) .470
  31. Brandon (2-4) .468
  32. Brock (8-0) .466
  33. Fraser Valley (5-4) .457
  34. Saint Mary's (4-5) .442
  35. York (3-8) .433
  36. Memorial (2-8) .427
  37. Laurentian (0-9) .416
  38. Thompson Rivers (3-6)
  39. RMC (0-9) .407
  40. Acadia (3-5) .407
  41. Manitoba (4-6) .405
  42. UNB (0-8) .398
  43. Winnipeg (2-8) .386

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Brock's 8-0 record was fashioned against competition that ranged from mediocre to feeble.
They played the likes of Laurentian, Winnipeg and Manitoba. They played RMC...twice. The best team they beat was Queen's and they have been hugely disappointing.
Last night, Ottawa U let the air out of the Badger's balloon with a 20 point win.
Tonight, Brock has to deal with the Ravens, from whom they borrowed the CIS championship.
Tonight, Carleton will politely ask Brock top hand it back.

Rob Pettapiece said...

No kidding on Brock. Before last night's games, they had faced opponents with a measly .151 winning percentage. (The next-lowest was almost 200 points higher.) Carleton should handle them tonight, with or without politeness.

Also, Queen's has had the third-toughest schedule in the country to this point, as Neate alluded to. That's why they're 15th with just a 4-7 record.